Skip to main content

Where to Find Ice Cream on Anna Maria Island, Cortez & Bradenton: A Local Guide to Cool Treats

There are few things that go better with a Florida Gulf Coast day than a cold ice cream cone.

Whether you’ve spent the afternoon on the beaches of Anna Maria Island, explored the fishing village of Cortez, or you’re simply looking for dessert after dinner in Bradenton, the area has plenty of places to satisfy a sweet tooth.

And this isn’t just a choice between chocolate and vanilla anymore. Around the Suncoast you’ll find old-fashioned homemade ice cream, frozen custard, Italian gelato, milkshakes, sundaes, frozen yogurt, Italian ice, sorbets and dairy-free selections.

Here’s a Suncoast Post guide to some of the ice cream and frozen-dessert stops worth knowing about around Anna Maria Island, Cortez and Bradenton.

Anna Maria Island

Two Scoops Ice Cream Parlor & Coffee Café

Located near the north end of the island, Two Scoops has been serving Anna Maria since 2007. The shop offers 32 flavors of ice cream, including everything from traditional favorites to flavors such as Sea Salt Caramel, Coffee Crunch, Gator Tracks and Trashcan. Sorbet and no-sugar selections are also available.

Address: 101 S. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria, FL 34216
Phone: 941-779-2422
Website

Dips Ice Cream

Dips Ice Cream has been part of Pine Avenue since 1993. In addition to more than 30 ice cream flavors, the shop combines the traditional ice cream parlor experience with candy and sports memorabilia. Italian ice and non-dairy choices have also been offered.

Address: 503 Pine Ave., Anna Maria, FL 34216
Phone: 941-778-1706
Website

Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff

Located in Holmes Beach, Holy Cow Ice Cream is a family-run island shop offering dozens of flavors along with milkshakes, malts, sundaes and soft serve. One thing that makes Holy Cow particularly useful for families and groups is its selection of alternatives, including vegan, sugar-free, gluten-free and lactose-free options.

Address: 3234 E. Bay Dr., Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Phone: 941-779-0690
Website

Small Town Creamery

Small Town Creamery in Holmes Beach offers more than just ice cream. The shop is also known for homemade fudge, waffle cones, coffee and sweet treats, giving families plenty of choices for an after-dinner stop.

Address: 5404 Marina Dr., Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Phone: 941-213-9107
Website

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai

For those who want something different from a traditional scoop shop, Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai offers a self-serve experience where customers can create their own frozen-yogurt or açaí combinations and add toppings. Customers can even combine frozen yogurt and açaí in the same bowl.

Address: 5604B Marina Dr., Holmes Beach, FL 34217
Phone: 941-213-9777
Website

Gelato-go Anna Maria Island

If Italian-style gelato is what you’re craving, Gelato-go has a location right on Historic Bridge Street in Bradenton Beach. The shop specializes in gelato along with coffee, making it an easy dessert stop while exploring one of the island’s most popular walking areas.

Address: 119 Bridge St., Unit 150, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217
Phone: 941-782-8414
Website

AMI Beach Hut

AMI Beach Hut combines an ice cream stop with a small island market. Located toward the north end of Anna Maria, it can be an especially convenient stop for visitors who want a scoop while picking up other beach-day necessities.

Address: 9901 Gulf Dr., Anna Maria, FL 34216
Phone: 941-281-2124

Cortez

Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream

Few local ice cream shops have a history quite like Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream.

Tyler’s has been making old-fashioned ice cream fresh on the premises since 1984. The Cortez shop serves hand-dipped ice cream along with sundaes, shakes, malts, floats and banana splits. Pints and quarts are also available to take home.

For generations of local families, an evening trip to Tyler’s has become as much a part of the Cortez experience as seafood and sunsets.

Address: 11904 Cortez Rd. W., Cortez, FL 34215
Phone: 941-794-5333
Website

Bradenton

SweetBerries Frozen Custard & Eatery

SweetBerries is a longtime Bradenton favorite that combines a full casual eatery with frozen custard.

In addition to sandwiches, salads and other lunch and dinner selections, SweetBerries offers frozen custard, shakes, sundaes and its popular blended “concretes.” The shop also features rotating custard flavors.

Address: 4500 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton, FL 34209
Phone: 941-750-6771
Website

Shake Pit

Bradenton residents have been visiting Shake Pit for decades. The old-school walk-up stand dates to 1959 and has become known for thick milkshakes, ice cream, burgers and crinkle-cut fries.

It remains one of those classic Bradenton destinations where the experience is almost as important as what you’re ordering.

Address: 3801 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-748-4016
Website

MilkShake Factory – Palma Sola

One of the newer dessert choices in West Bradenton is MilkShake Factory, where the focus is squarely on premium milkshakes.

The company makes its ice cream in-house and combines it with fruit, chocolate and other ingredients for handspun shakes. The store also sells chocolates, including chocolate bark and other confections. Non-dairy shake selections are available as well.

Address: 7230 Manatee Ave. W., Unit 13, Bradenton, FL 34209
Phone: 941-253-5699
Website

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice gives Bradenton another option when traditional ice cream isn’t quite what you’re after.

The menu includes Italian ice, soft ice cream and the company’s signature Jelati, which layers Italian ice with soft ice cream.

Address: 2525 Manatee Ave. W., Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-900-2755
Website

Goodies Gelato & Coffee

Goodies Gelato & Coffee combines gelato with coffee, matcha and other specialty drinks. The Bradenton shop has developed a following for creative presentation as well as its gelato selections.

Address: 455 Cortez Rd. W., Bradenton, FL 34207
Phone: 941-226-1309

Ice Cream La Oaxaqueña

For something completely different, Ice Cream La Oaxaqueña offers a Mexican-style ice cream shop experience. Its offerings include ice cream, paletas, fruit desserts, mangonadas, aguas frescas and traditional Mexican snacks.

Address: 2201 14th St. W., Bradenton, FL 34205
Phone: 941-896-4650

More Than Just Dessert

One of the best things about ice cream on the Florida Suncoast is that it fits just about any occasion.

It can be the final stop after seafood in Cortez, a reward for the kids after spending the afternoon at the beach, part of an evening walk along Pine Avenue or Bridge Street, or simply an excuse to get out of the house for an old-fashioned milkshake.

And while national chains have their place, this part of Florida still has an impressive collection of independent and family-operated ice cream businesses. Some have been scooping for decades, while newer businesses are adding gelato, frozen yogurt, açaí bowls and specialty milkshakes to the mix.

Make an Ice Cream Tour Out of It

Here’s an idea for locals who think they’ve already seen everything the area has to offer: create your own Suncoast Ice Cream Tour.

Start at the north end of Anna Maria Island, work your way through Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach, cross the bridge into Cortez for Tyler’s, and then continue east into Bradenton.

You certainly don’t have to visit them all in one day — although we won’t judge you if you try.

With homemade ice cream, frozen custard, gelato, Italian ice, frozen yogurt and some serious milkshakes waiting along the way, staying cool on the Florida Suncoast has rarely tasted this good.

Suncoast Post Tip: Hours can change seasonally, particularly at smaller island businesses. Before making a special trip, check the business’s website or call ahead for current hours.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to content